It Didn’t Start With You

Reading Journey

  • Started: 2024-12-24T17:41:07Z
  • Ended: 2024-12-25T11:03:21Z
  • Total Time Read: 2hrs 7mins 11secs
Code
%run _help_reading.py
import pandas as pd

df = pd.read_csv(
  'https://github.com/MrGeislinger/victorsothervector/raw/main/'
  'data/reading/all_reading-clean.csv'
)

book_name = """It Didn't Start With You"""
one_title = one_title_data(df, book_name)
one_title_summary = get_summary_by_day(one_title)
generate_plot(one_title_summary, book_name);
Figure 1: Reading done for It Didn’t Start With You

Thoughts on It Didn’t Start With You

Overview

Book that talks about trauma that can be passed done to later generations. Talks about how to resolve that trauma by going back up the generations for the source. Frankly I didn’t like it

Too many red flags early on where I knew I wasn’t going to like this

Regardless of the actual material and stance (which I find suspicious on its own), this book does not give me confidence of its efficacy.

There are only stories that have happy resolutions stemming from the idea of ‘inherited trauma’. And there does not seem any reference to evidence this is true and actually helps outside these stories. There are citations but looking carefully, they are quite a few pre-1960 references and usually are only citing the adjacent science versus anything directly related to this ‘inherited trauma’.

I think this was a book I just grabbed from the library over a recommendation. Which seems likely because I don’t think anyone in my circles would have ever even mentioned this book if they read it.

I’m suspicious of books like this where I’m used to more ‘science-based’ books


Bluesky Comments